At Worship Matters Bob Kauflin has listed some websites and individual resources that are helpful in locating Christmas songs.
He has links to sites with arrangements for traditional carols; along with recommendations of Christmas albums, contemporary songs, children’s choir pieces and a link to Christianity Today’s review of some of this year’s release of Christmas albums.
Here are his individual contemporary recommendations.
New (or fairly new) Songs (congregational and solo)
Here With Us – Joy Williams – ponders the apparent paradoxes of God becoming a baby to save usJesus Saves – Travis Cottrell – travels from the incarnation, to the cross, to our praise in the new heavens and earthAdore Him – Kari Jobe – describes the adoration of the Magi, and uses the chorus of “O Come all Ye Faithful”My Soul Magnifies the Lord – Chris TomlinJoy to the World (Unspeakable Joy) – Chris Tomlin – celebratory version with a new chorus
On Christmas Day – Matt OsgoodSon of God – Michael W SmithGlorious Impossible – Carl Cartee – joyful celebration of Christ’s birth, life, and substitutionary deathHe Made a Way in a Manger – Vicky BeechingHe is Wonderful – Kathryn ScottGod Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen – MercyMe
Older Songs (congregational and solo)Labor of Love – Andrew Peterson – beautiful portrayal of Mary’s humility in birthing JesusFrom the Squalor – Stuart Townend – one of my favorite Christmas hymns that covers Jesus’ birth, life, death, and returnWhen Love Came Down to Earth – Stuart TownendMagnificat – Todd Agnew – a contemporary version of Mary’s songHere I Am to Worship – Tim Hughes